Fractals make better superconductors

Superconductivity, where a material conducts electricity at very low temperature with no resistance, and therefore transmission wastes virtually no energy, has applications ranging from medical scanners to maglev trains. Until now, scientists have focused on atomic-scale phenomena to explain this mysterious property of some special compounds. But in this week’s Nature, a team from Rome, Grenoble and London report that the strength of the superconductivity – its ability to persist as temperature is increased– correlates in certain oxide materials with structures visible over a range of length scales. Intriguingly, these structures extend almost to the millimeter scale, and have a “fractal” nature, similar to the intricate patterns in a snowflake.

Since the discovery of superconductivity at the beginning of the last century, there has been a constant quest for improved performance in the form of higher operating temperatures and capacity to carry electrical power. A major breakthrough occurred in 1987 when two scientists from IBM discovered that oxides of copper, previously thought to be most unlikely candidates for superconductivity, superconduct at unprecedentedly high temperatures. Since then, this class of materials continues to hold the record for operating temperatures, well above the boiling temperature of inexpensive liquid nitrogen. At the same time, though, there is no agreement as to the mechanism underlying this high performance, even though a clear understanding would be extremely beneficial for engineers.

Until now, scientists have focused on structure at the nanometer (0.0000001 millimeters) – the distance between neighbouring atoms - scale as the determinant of the unusually strong superconductivity of the oxides of copper. For this week’s Nature article, the researchers used the new technique of X-ray microscopy to examine a copper oxide superconductor whose internal structure could be changed via simple heat treatments – an approach employed by ceramicists over millennia to modify oxide materials.

The team discovered that the best superconductivity was obtained when the microstructure was most ‘connected’, meaning that it is possible to trace a path with the same nanostructure (exhibited by oxygen atoms) over a large distance. The microstructure in this case was ‘fractal’: if we were to zoom in on the material’s structure at increasing levels of magnification, its appearance would remain the same.

Co-author Antonio Bianconi of the University Rome noted that “We are very excited by our results because they show that fractals, which are ubiquitous in both the biological sciences and the social sciences where they are even used to contemplate the behaviour of financial markets, now appear to have a significant impact on a fundamental property of inorganic matter, its superconductivity. ” Co-author Gabriel Aeppli of the London Centre for Nanotechnology and University College London, added that “While there is no detailed theoretical explanation for what we have discovered yet, it demonstrates that classical ceramic engineering – with visible effects at near millimeter scales – can collude with quantum physics to produce the best superconductors.”

The article is published in Nature (doi:10.1038/nature09260) on 12 Aug 2010. Click here to see the article and associated News and Views on Nature's website.

Illustration: Heat treatment improves the superconductivity of a ceramic copper oxide by creating a fractal network of connected channels of ordered oxygen defects. The green and red spheres represent the paired electrons responsible for superconductivity. Artwork by Manuel Vogtli (LCN)

Professor Antonio Bianconi is available for interview and can be contacted on telephone no +39 3388438281 or email address: 
Professor Gabriel Aeppli is available for interview and can be contacted on +44-20 7679 0055 or email address:

About the London Centre for Nanotechnology: The London Centre for Nanotechnology is an interdisciplinary joint enterprise between University College London and Imperial College London. In bringing together world-class infrastructure and leading nanotechnology research activities, the Centre has the critical mass to compete with the best facilities world-wide. Research programmes are aligned to three key areas, namely Planet Care, Healthcare and Information Technology and exploit core competencies in the biomedical, physical and engineering sciences. Website:
About UCL (University College London): Founded in 1826, UCL was the first English university established after Oxford and Cambridge, the first to admit students regardless of race, class, religion or gender, and the first to provide systematic teaching of law, architecture and medicine. UCL is the fourth-ranked university in the 2009 THES-QS World University Rankings. UCL alumni include Marie Stopes, Jonathan Dimbleby, Lord Woolf, Alexander Graham Bell, and members of the band Coldplay. UCL currently has over 12,000 undergraduate and 8,000 postgraduate students. Its annual income is over £600 million. Website:


UCL Press Office – David Weston tel. +44-20 7679 7678 or


About Sapienza University of Rome: The “Studium Urbis” was founded in 1303. In the 1650s the university became known as Sapienza, meaning wisdom, a title it retains. It moved in into the new building “La Sapienza” with the famous University chapel Sant’Ivo built by Francesco Borromini in the XVII century. In 1872 became the national university of the capital of Italy. In 1935 moved to the new university campus, designed by a group of excellent Italian modern architects. Between its professors and alumni it is worth to mention Enrico Fermi, Salvador Luria, Emilio Segré, Ettore Majorana, and Ugo Fano. Today the main campus is located in Piazzale Aldo Moro. The Rector of the University is Luigi Frati. Sapienza University is by far the largest university in Europe, with 140.000 students and more than 100 buildings, and it is a leading centre of research and academic excellence in many fields of knowledge; physics, biomedical sciences, humanities, engineering and natural sciences, with established cooperation programmers with major international universities.

Sapienza Press office - Alessandra Barberis tel. (+39) 06 4991 0034 or


About ESRF: The European Synchrotron Radiation Facility operates the largest facility for research with X-rays in Europe. Each year 7000 researchers travel to Grenoble (France) to conduct some 1500 different experiments, all at the cutting edge of modern science. About 1600 publications on work done at the ESRF are published in international refereed journals every year. Physicists work side-by-side with chemists and materials scientists. Biologists, medical doctors, meteorologists, geophysicists, archaeologists and palaeontologists have become regular users. Industrial applications are also growing, notably in the fields
of pharmaceuticals, cosmetics, petrochemicals and microelectronics.


ESRF Press office - Montserrat Capellas, tel. (+33) 476 88 26 63 or


Attached image
Fractal network of superconductivity in ceramic copper oxide